Suppose you believe in the personality theory.

假设你相信人格理论。

So I don't exist at Phase D on the personality theory.

所以我在D阶段不存在这是人格理论的结论。

What if instead we accept the personality theory?

那么如果我们接受人格理论又如何呢？

What should we say about Phase D, on the personality theory?

对于D阶段 人格理论会如何解读呢？

That's still not me, on the personality theory.

根据人格理论 那还不是我。

The personality theory must be false.

如此以来 人格理论必定是错的。

That's what the personality theory it gives us the answer we're looking for in the ordinary case.

这就是我们在一般情况下从人格理论得出的答案。

What is the personality theory going to say about this case?

人格理论该怎样解释这种情况呢？

No problem here for the personality theory.

这个异议无法颠覆人格理论。

It's not really a counterexample to the personality theory.

无法作为人格理论的一个反例。

One belief, even one very unusual belief's not enough to make somebody Napoleon, according to the personality theory.

一个信念 哪怕是个极与众不同的信念根据人格理论，也不足以证明这个人就是拿破仑。

So the personality theory's got to be rejected.

那么人格理论被驳回了。

That's what the personality theory says.

这就是人格理论得出的结论。

According to the personality theory, whether somebody is me depends on whether he's got my beliefs.

根据人格理论，判断一个人是不是我取决于他有没有我的信念。

The personality theory or the body theory?

人格理论还是肉体理论？

Look at all the problems you've got adopting the personality theory.

就为了接受人格理论给自己搞出这么多问题。

Yet, the personality theory, the objection says, would tell us that he is Napoleon because he's got the beliefs of Napoleon.

但是这个异议指出 人格理论会说，他就是拿破仑因为他有拿破仑的信念。

In which case, what you're discovering is you don't really believe the personality theory.

这种情况下 你发现自己其实并不相信人格理论。

That is, that is what the personality theory has to say about that case.

这就是人格理论所作的恰当解释。

And if you do agree, that shows you don't really accept the personality theory.

如果你同意，那就意味着你并不接受人格理论。