So far, the judges of the Appellate Division had failed to hand down a decision, but after another postponement they finally affirmed the decree of the lower court—two justices dissenting. A notice of appeal was served upon Edward Shuttleworth.

迄今为止，上诉庭的法官未能作出裁决，但在又一次拖延之后，他们终于确认了下级法院的判决——两名法官持不同意见。上诉通知已送达爱德华沙特尔沃思。